Enjoying what you’re reading? Sign up now.

Subscribe
Search

Accessory Myth: “Accessory sales will take away from F&I sales.”

Man pulled in two directions
Article Highlights:

  • Customers don't typically associate accessories with the car deal.
  • "It gives them mental ownership of the vehicle."

The third accessory myth in our series that I hear is, “adding accessories into the vehicle sales process will take away from F&I.” These dealers believe customers who spend money on additional, expensive accessories will be less likely to buy F&I products. While this concern is understandable, you will be happy to learn accessory sales typically do not harm F&I sales.

In fact, selling accessories has the potential to help boost F&I profits. After personalizing their new vehicle, customers may be more likely to buy protection and warranty products in the F&I office. Why? Because they feel more attached to the vehicle and want to protect its new, personalized features.

Another reason dealerships shy away from selling accessories is because they fear buyers will be “oversold” by the time they get to the F&I office. Dealers think transitioning customers from one sales pitch to another, and then another will burn them out, so they are less inclined to actively participate in the F&I process and buy F&I products.

This unease is also unwarranted, especially when you present accessories as a shopping experience—not a sales pitch. We learned earlier in this series that customers are going to buy accessories whether you offer them or not. For this reason, we’ve found that customers don’t typically associate the accessory presentation as part of the car deal. It is something they were planning to do anyway, so it is a welcome opportunity to get it all done at once and even add it into their financing.

Without an accessory presentation to engage them, customers are more likely to be on their phones getting bored or anxious. Offering accessories breaks up the time between sales and the F&I office, keeping customers engaged in the buying process. They stay busy and don’t think about the time spent at the dealership.

If you are on the fence about selling accessories, you don’t need to worry about drops in F&I sales. An effective accessory presentation keeps customers engaged in the purchase and increases their ownership of the vehicle. F&I departments should welcome and leverage this opportunity to close additional F&I sales.

Stay tuned for the next Accessory Myth article in an upcoming edition of Fuel.

Share this Article

Director, Reynolds Consulting Services

Carl Bennett is the vice president of customer success services. This team, under Bennet’s leadership, teaches automotive retailers in the U.S. and Canada how to achieve higher levels of success and better results throughout their dealership. Bennet has spent over 15 years with Reynolds, helping dealerships through training, consulting, and installation roles. Prior to joining Reynolds, Bennett worked in dealerships for 15 years as a general manager, finance director, and sales manager.

Related Articles:

How to Leverage Predictive Analytics to Boost Sales Opportunities

14 years. That’s how long the average consumer is holding onto their vehicle, and this trend isn’t shifting anytime soon. When consumers hold onto their

The Future of Variable Ops with Experts at NADA 2025

Explore how AI is transforming variable operations in automotive retailing with insights from NADA 2025. Learn about efficiency, profitability, and fraud prevention from industry leaders.

Decision made regarding the Vehicle Shopping Rule – now what?

Check out five key takeaways from the Vehicle Shopping Rule to keep your dealership safe from FTC enforcement actions.

Image of a car with Information about it highlighted above the image.

3 Ways AI Can Elevate Your Dealership’s Online Inventory

On average, Americans are exposed to between 4,000 and 10,000 advertisements every day. From commercials on TV to billboards on your way to work, all