Enjoying what you’re reading? Sign up now.


Lessons from Sears on Adaption

Abandoned Sears store
Article Highlights:

  • How Sears failed to adapt to customer demands.
  • Invest in differentiation that brings customers back.

It’s important to take time and reflect every now and then. It helps us make sure we have learned something in preparation for the future. Even headlines outside of the auto industry can provide insight on what to do, or what not to do, especially in a changing marketplace.

Sears’ decisions are perfect examples of what not to do when faced with inevitable change. Sears was a staple, a trusted brand, a go-to store. Then the retail apocalypse happened. Sears’ shares dropped 45% in just five days.1 Sears may have survived if they had appropriately invested in the future of their company, but they didn’t.

Maybe saving every penny didn’t seem like giving up at the time, but in hindsight it was a big contributor to Sears’ downfall. Sears reinvested a measly 1% into their company, which went towards their virtual store.2 It did not go into enhancing their physical locations where their products meet their customers. They made the decision to focus their future on online sales, rather than in-store sales.

Sears could have done better. They thought a changing marketplace meant completely changing their business model rather than finding new ways for their current model to thrive. But the retail apocalypse wasn’t a death sentence. Otherwise, Kohl’s would have declared bankruptcy, too.

Kohl’s faced the same industry perils but responded in a much different way. First, they made sure they were getting everything right with retail basics, like increasing their private-label and exclusive brands selection, reducing clutter and increasing visual appeal, and making sure they had plenty of staff available for fast help and checkout.

Once they had the basics down, they were able to invest in their company and take more risks. They partner with Amazon to sell products like Alexa, and accept return packages for any Amazon order to get customers in their store. They offer Wi-Fi to their customers, allowing them to track their customer’s in-store activity and block competitor sites like Macy’s. They also started a Millennial initiative called the “outfit bar” that allows women to shop based on style and occasion instead of by brand.3

The focus of Kohl’s strategy is polar opposite to Sears. Sears tried to move away from a physical store and bet against their traditional model. Kohl’s invested in their employees and their in-store experience. They found clever ways to bring the customer in, and keep them there.


The most strategic response you can make today is to invest in your dealership’s future. Invest in your employees. Invest in your processes. Improve your store’s experience to respond to consumer demands. Mystery shop your own dealership to ensure all departments are following the processes you have put in place.

Keep in mind, turnover of personnel can cause a turnover in your processes. When was the last time you had your finance department shopped to verify they are offering your products and ensuring compliance? Does your dealership maximize profits by offering aftermarket products after the vehicle sale, rather than negotiating them at point of sale? Does your service department perform a quality vehicle walk-around for every customer that comes through your service drive?

It’s easier said than done. After all, Sears did invest in their company. They made a move to respond to market changes. But they made the wrong choice. It can be hard to realize which improvements are the right ones when you’re so close to your situation. An industry expert specializing in process improvements and strategic insight can help you make sure you’re leading your dealership to success.


  1. Yahoo! Finance News
  2. Yahoo! Finance News
  3. CNN Business

Share this Article

Director, Reynolds Consulting Services

Carl Bennett is the director of North American Consulting Operations and Sales for Reynolds Consulting Services. In his consultant role, Bennett teaches automotive retailers in the U.S. and Canada how to achieve higher levels of success and better results in vehicle sales and F&I. Prior to joining Reynolds and Reynolds more than 15 years ago, Bennett worked in dealerships for 15 years as a general manager, finance director, and sales manager.

Related Articles:

Customer incoming message

There’s No Ghosting in Automotive

Have you or your sales team ever been ghosted by a customer? Being left with no response can be frustrating, especially when it can happen

Woman cleaning desk

Spring Cleaning: De-clunking and De-cluttering in F&I

A year in the life of a dealership is a long time, but it can pass quickly. Before you know it, another fiscal year begins,

Computer on left, couple looking at car on right

Operating Differently in Sales: How to Align the Online and In-Store…

Instead of simply adding online options and hoping for the best, you need to run your sales process differently so you can easily pivot between

Visualization and Customization: Why They’re Important to Your…

How many times have you gone in to buy a phone, and you think you have a pretty good idea of what you’re buying? You